What Are the APEASE Criteria Used For?
The Behaviour Change Wheel (in French), published by Michie, van Stralen, and West (2011), links barriers to a behavior with intervention functions that could address them. Michie, Atkins, and West’s 2014 design guide introduces the APEASE criteria for judging how well those options fit the setting. Teams can use the criteria to choose among intervention functions and then compare specific ways to put those functions into practice.
The COM-B model helps explain what makes a behavior easier or harder. APEASE comes into play once the team has plausible ways to address what it found. UNICEF Innocenti’s 2023 guide applies the criteria to intervention functions, the strategies used to deliver them, and the specific behavior change techniques (in French) under consideration. The details of delivery can change which option makes sense.
What Are the Six APEASE Criteria?
Affordability asks whether the organization can pay for the option at the intended scale, including setup and ongoing costs. Practicability asks whether people can deliver it as planned, given the time and staffing available. Effectiveness and cost-effectiveness concern the expected result and what it costs to achieve. The budget tells you what you can fund. Cost-effectiveness helps show what each option delivers for the resources it uses.
Acceptability considers how the option is received by the people who will use it, deliver it, or be affected by it. Side effects and safety cover unintended consequences, beneficial as well as adverse. Equity asks whether the option narrows or widens gaps between groups working under different conditions. The guide for the UK government by West and colleagues (2020) sets out these questions with attention to the scale of delivery and who the intervention actually reaches.
How Do You Apply APEASE to Two Interventions?
Back to the fictional billing example. Suppose observing the month-end close shows that project managers spend too much time matching recorded hours to billable work. In the first option, the portal pulls the data into a prefilled billing summary that the project manager checks before sending. In the second, someone from accounting prepares the summary with the project manager during a scheduled session. Both address the same problem and divide the work differently.
Prefilling is worth a closer look if the records match and unusual cases are easy to spot. The joint session is feasible if accounting can handle the projects in scope and keep its other month-end work on schedule. Project managers, accounting, and the portal administrator can assess those conditions together. The grid shows what the team would need to check for each option.
| Criterion | Prefilled Summary in the Portal | Joint Session with Accounting |
|---|---|---|
| Affordability What expenses does the budget need to cover? |
Estimate the cost of changes to the portal, ongoing updates, and handling exceptions. | Estimate the accounting time needed at each close and the cost of arranging coverage if needed. |
| Practicability Can the team deliver the option at the intended scale? |
Check whether the data can be matched correctly for each type of contract. | Check how many projects accounting and project managers can handle together before the deadline. |
| Effectiveness and cost-effectiveness What result can we expect for the resources used? |
Track the share of summaries sent on time that need no later correction. Compare the gain with setup and ongoing costs. | Track the same results and account for the time both departments spend each month. |
| Acceptability How do the people affected view the option? |
Find out whether project managers understand the prefilled data and find it practical to check. | Ask project managers and accounting staff what they think of the scheduled session and the split in responsibilities. |
| Side effects and safety What unintended consequences should we track? |
Look for errors carried forward from one month to the next, even as preparation gets faster. | See whether the session improves coordination or delays other month-end work. |
| Equity Who benefits, and who still faces barriers? |
Compare standard and nonstandard contracts to see where manual reentry is still needed. | Check whether teams with different closing schedules can get comparable support. |
If the portal matches data accurately for standard contracts and accounting has little time to spare at month-end, leadership can start by piloting prefilled summaries for those contracts. The pilot will track the share of summaries sent on time and any corrections requested after delivery. Extending the approach to nonstandard contracts will depend on how well the system matches those records and how much time people spend handling exceptions.
How Do You Decide When the Criteria Point in Different Directions?
Start with the facts that could change the decision. If an option depends on a team already committed to other work at the time it needs to step in, the person in charge has to free up that team’s time or redesign the option. The expected effect depends on whether people can deliver it when they need to. West and colleagues’ 2019 guide for local government recommends recording the reasoning and revising or dropping options that fail on a criterion.
Acceptability and equity can point to different conclusions. A team might welcome an intervention it helped design while the benefits go mostly to people who already have the best access to the tools. To understand the difference, the project team can ask the people affected what they think and look at which working conditions make the option easier to use. The 2019 guide advocates involving stakeholders in that assessment early in the design.
What Should a Pilot Check?
The criteria help identify which uncertainties the pilot needs to resolve. If the question is effectiveness, track a behavioral indicator (in French) tied to the target action and measure the business outcome separately. If the question is practicability, check what people were able to put in place and how much time it took. Together, those measures help tell whether the problem lies in delivery or in the effect of an intervention delivered as planned.
A pilot can also surface unintended consequences and differences between groups. A time saving in one department might move rework to another. A positive average result might mask differences between teams using different tools. The person responsible can use those findings to improve the intervention or limit rollout to the conditions where the results support it.
Where Does APEASE Fit in the MEET© Protocol?
In the MEET© protocol, the team uses APEASE in Engineer, after specifying the behavior and investigating the barriers. It records the reasons for its choice, what needs to be in place for the pilot, and what it still needs to learn. In Experiment, the pilot puts some of those assumptions to the test. The findings help the team decide whether to continue, revise, or stop the intervention.
In Transfer, the team considers what it would take to operate at a larger scale. The time people have to support the practice varies across teams. Before extending the intervention, the person in charge reassesses what it will take to deliver in day-to-day work.
Frequently Asked Questions
Should you score each APEASE criterion?
Scoring can help when several options are still viable. West and colleagues’ 2020 guide suggests weighting the criteria after revising or dropping options that fail on one. Record the fact, assumption, or disagreement behind each assessment. That record shows what needs another look if conditions change.
Can APEASE be used after an intervention has rolled out?
Yes. The people delivering the intervention can compare current conditions with what they expected at launch. If replacing a work tool makes the intervention harder to use, for example, reassess its practicability. Observed effects and feedback from the people using it can help the team decide what to change.
Why do sources list the six criteria in a different order?
The two A’s stand for affordability and acceptability. The Public Health England guides list acceptability first and affordability fourth. The UNREST Tools page lists affordability first. Both versions ask what the people funding the intervention can support and what the people using or delivering it will accept.
References
London Metropolitan University, Performance with Purpose Research Centre, and UNICEF Innocenti (2023). Evidence-based intervention design for behaviour change during a health emergency: A toolkit based upon the COM-B model and Behaviour Change Wheel. UNICEF Innocenti guide
Michie, S., Atkins, L., and West, R. (2014). The Behaviour Change Wheel: A Guide to Designing Interventions. Silverback Publishing. Book website
Michie, S., van Stralen, M. M., and West, R. (2011). The behaviour change wheel: A new method for characterising and designing behaviour change interventions. Implementation Science, 6, 42. 10.1186/1748-5908-6-42
West, R., Michie, S., Atkins, L., Chadwick, P., and Lorencatto, F. (2019). Achieving behaviour change: A guide for local government and partners. Public Health England. Local government guide
West, R., Michie, S., Chadwick, P., Atkins, L., and Lorencatto, F. (2020). Achieving behaviour change: A guide for national government. Public Health England. National government guide
About the Author
Maxime Rabéchault is the founder and president of UNREST, a change enablement consultancy. He applies behavioral science to organizational transformation and leadership development.
.webp)
